One of many reviewer’s complaints is that the book known “my” an such like because determiners, when they were indeed (inside the advice) pronouns
– I actually do trust you throughout the staying conditions down inside courses, and that i offer your one to students are much planning to know what adjectives is actually than determiners.
In reality, I think I just relate to “my”etc because possessives in case the you prefer arises, and that is not that commonly (they won’t seem to end up in of a lot damage to Polish learners, at the least). But course guides from time to time make reference to determiners, therefore i have to be able to identify them.
The idea I was and then make so you’re able to Syed Usman was that it is hazardous to talk in absolutes from inside the code. Just because their language community and you can mine make reference to “my” etc because determiners and you can “mine” an such like given that “possessive pronouns” this does not mean that someone else speaing frankly about “my” etcetera due to the fact possessive pronouns are fundamentally incorrect. That’s surely exactly how many linguists make reference to him or her, like.
I learned that it the hard ways. I’d merely created a blog post getting my web log towards the determiners and you will pronouns, when i noticed a rather (unfairly in my opinion) poor report on an enthusiastic EFL sentence structure book for the a weblog having a distinctly linguistics slant. When i dared so you can feedback this particular was definitely basic for the EFL, he cited Huddleston and you will Pullum during the myself, and i also gotten a good lecture in the “determinatives” (that i got never heard about – none I think, have many some body).
When i was rather worried I would personally started using it most of the wrong in the my blog post, I did so a bit of research to your entire determiner / determinative issue (it is a touch of in pretty bad shape), and therefore my personal mention of those two reference guides. But i have you to solid idea to my site, that’s that we use the main-stream words from EFL, so I’m adhering to the product quality EFL and you can dictionary concept of determiner I might currently used, and you may leaving brand new odd and great posts with the linguists..
I consent. If the people asked just what good determiner are, I’d just let them have an inventory. BTW inside the Hungarian, palms is completed with noun endings not independent conditions.
In spite of how I view it, ‘Mine and Greg’s’ seems to be best
First, you have the target, which is the ‘child.’ And after that you have the a couple of possessors, ‘Greg,’ and the pronoun for ‘yourself.’ Depending on and this person you may be creating inside, the issue of the process varies. Earliest body’s dreadful which have compound possessives!
Bring it having a whole grain away from salt; my personal super-super-chill certificates lay in the of a lot treacherous and unedited areas off Fanfiction; I would not be shocked if i try deciding on so it entirely backwards!
And, while in doubt, was stating this new phrase out loud. ‘My and you can Greg’s child’ versus ‘Mine and Greg’s child’–what type tunes better? You are sure that what type I might fit into. Just sayin’.
– and there lays an element of the situation: it is not clear independent from whether we use ‘my’ otherwise ‘mine’. (We note that in my own first review I’d presumed they was talking of just one guy,but into next look I would really imagine one or two was indeed becoming referred to.
In addition to this it appears to be to me abnormal to own causes I mentioned earlier. The individual had already pulled the child/pupils to school, so allegedly knew its identity(s) – so why not use only its labels in lieu of so it a little awkward framework?
Incidentally I can not go along with Ashley:) – as far as i learn, i practically avoid using possessive pronouns up until the people or procedure could have been said (but possibly in-book headings). “Greg’s kid and you can exploit” might just functions, if truth be told there a couple of children, or even more, however, “Exploit and you can Greg’s man”? I believe not.
